Writing in Open Democracy, Des Freedman, co-editor of The Assault on Universities: A Manifesto for Resistance, detects a whiff of hypocrisy in Sun associate editor Trevor Kavanagh’s complaints about the arrests at the newspaper:
Kavanagh rages, in a lengthy piece in today’s Sun, that the Guardian-inspired ‘witch hunt’, which culminated in the arrest last weekend of senior Sun journalists (together with a police officer, an Army major and a MoD employee), ‘has put us behind ex-Soviet states in Press freedom’. The UK is now, according to a recent Reporters without Borders analysis, 28th in the World Press Freedom Index.
Except that what Kavanagh fails to point out is that, according to the report, the UK has dropped down the league table because of two things: ‘its approach to the protection of privacy and its response to the London riots’, neither of them issues in which the Sun, nor indeed McKenzie himself, can claim to have a proud record.
However Freedman also argues that advocates of media reform need to take seriously concerns about press freedom and should not allow the Murdoch empire to get away with turning a few journalists into scapegoats:
Advocates of a democratic media need to argue that reforms—such as those proposed by the Media Reform campaign for a right of reply, for a new accountable press body to monitor news organisations and for levies to fund new types of news ventures (discussed in OurKingdom here)—will actually enable the press to act more ethically and responsibly than they are able to do under regimes which are committed to serving shareholders more than readers. Far from shackling journalists, robust and democratic regulation that is independent of both government and the news barons will actually empower journalists to do their job.
The corruption that has been revealed in recent events is a structural matter and not one confined to a few ‘bad apples’, much as Murdoch would no doubt like to argue at the moment given News Corp’s sudden willingness to identify ‘wrongdoers’. The recent arrests and the evidence provided to Leveson provide the clearest demonstration yet that phone hacking and illegal payments go far beyond individual journalists and the now deceased News of the World and are instead symptomatic of a top-down corporate news culture.
Visit Open Democracy to read the article in full.
For a guide to journalism based on honesty, integrity and independence we highly recommend David Randall’s acclaimed The Universal Journalist, available now in a fully updated and expanded fourth edition.
A Manifesto for Resistance
Edited by Michael Bailey and Des Freedman
Sharp essays take on the government’s agenda of university cuts and fee increases, and outline an alternative manifesto for higher education.
“The corporatising of universal education is one of the most insidious and dangerous attacks on the very notion of human rights. This book calls us to arms. Every student, every educator who cares should read it.” – John Pilger
“This is an essential book. The future of our universities is up for grabs and the manifesto will play a huge role in providing alternatives at a time when the government says there aren’t any.” – Clare Solomon, President of the University of London Union (ULU) 2010-11 and editor of Springtime (2011)
New updated edition of the world’s leading handbook on journalism.
“What I admire about this book is that it is not simply a ‘How to’ manual – although it covers ‘How to’ and ‘How not to’ brilliantly; it is also a wise, witty and extremely entertaining read… Anyone who aspires to be a journalist – in any of the media – should read Randall. If they don’t, they will, as I did, waste an awful lot of valuable time.” – Dame Ann Leslie, British Journalism Review
“Easily the best introduction to being a reporter I have come across. It provides solid, no-nonsense advice on the skills needed to do the job but is also willing to tackle the bigger issues every journalist must grapple with from time to time. Best of all, it has been written by a true newsman and his enthusiasm for the task in hand is evident on every page.” – Paul Jones, course leader, Press Association Editorial Training